Rev. Charles C. Pise, 1849–1866
Rev. Francis J. Freel, 1866–1884
Rev. Thomas F. Ward, 1884–1898
Rev. James E. Bobier, 1898–1918
Rev. Msgr. Thomas J. O’Brien, 1919–1926
Rev. Ambrose P. Dunnigan, 1928–1939
Rev. Msgr. John J. Robinson, 1940–1941
Rev. Msgr. Ambrose S. Aitken, 1941–1959
Very Rev. Msgr. Charles E. Diviney, 1959–1978
Rev. Msgr. Francis J. Murphy, 1978–1989
Rev. Charles A. Kraus, 1989–2007
Rev. Msgr. Alfred LoPinto, 2007-2008, 2016-2017 (Administrator)
Rev. Msgr. Edward P. Doran, 2008–2016
Rev. William G. Smith, 2017-2023
Very Rev. Joseph Gibino, 2023-present